Addendum to Ps 74:11 - Why withdrawest thou thy hand, even thy right hand? from midst of thy bosom completely.
The Hebrew Text:
לָמָּה תָשִׁיב יָדְךָ וִימִינֶךָ מִקֶּרֶב חֵיקְךָ כַלֵּה
lama tashiv yadcha viyminecha miqerev cheyqcha kaleh
The problem with SMT and KJV:
Both split this into two phrases:
1. Why withdrawest thou thy hand, even thy right hand?
2. from midst of thy bosom completely.
First is a complete sentence. Second is a dependent clause with no verb. It makes no sense alone and creates controversy over what kaleh does.
Hebrew is one verse, one verb, one thought.
Three words are misunderstood:
1. lama - למה
Usually translated why, but in lament Psalms where context is ad-matay - until when / how long, lama carries same force: until when, how long will you...?
Same Psalm:
Ps 74:9...neither is there among us any that knoweth ad-matay - until when.
Ps 74:10 ad-matay - how long shall adversary reproach?
Ps 74:11 lama - until when will you...?
It is continuation of same question - until when, not just why. This avoids having to add not - Until when will you return your hand...? is natural lament.
2. tashiv - תשיב - Hiphil of shuv - שוב
Means to turn back, return, bring back, restore. With preposition mi - from, direction is FROM.
tashiv yadcha miqerev cheyqcha = return your hand FROM midst of your bosom - i.e. bring it back out, not put it back in.
KJV withdrawest reads it as putting hand into bosom. Hebrew with mi reads as bringing hand out FROM bosom.
3. kaleh - כלה - H3615
Last word with no object. Means to bring to complete end, to finish, to complete, to consume, to accomplish completely.
As verb consume them - must add them - ERV, BSB: pluck it out of thy bosom and consume them.
As adverb completely, unto the end - LXX: apo mesou tou kolpou sou eis telos - from midst of thy bosom for ever / unto the end / completely.
LXX is oldest witness and chose completely, not destroy them.
NET, Keil & Delitzsch note pregnant construction: out of midst of thy bosom, destroy - is pregnant for drawing forth hand that rests inactive there.
What the verse actually says as one complete sentence:
Until when wilt thou return thy hand, even thy right hand, from midst of thy bosom completely?
Or interrogative:
Why wilt thou not return thy hand, even thy right hand, from midst of thy bosom completely?
Why completely matters in context:
Psalm 74 context is Temple and synagogues burned [74:7-8]. Enemy blasphemes Name [74:18]. Israel in captivity.
Halfway pulling Right Hand out only destroys enemy - Temple still burned.
Completely - kaleh - means in full restorative power - to destroy what needs destroying AND to finish / rebuild what was desolate - to bring to perfect completion.
Right Hand is Yah, hidden in bosom of Father, as Son in bosom of Father [John 1:18], hidden in dark waters and thick clouds [Ps 18:11 ab - thick clouds = root of bosom]. To be drawn out of many waters [Ps 18:16] to restore.
Thus Psalm 74:11 is prayer for Right Hand to come completely out of bosom - not half - to reveal power fully for restoration of both houses to land.
Compose
Write to Meta AI
Here's a rewritten and tightened version of the blog post draft I gave you earlier. I've kept all the key layers intact but woven in גדי (the young goat/kid = 17) prominently—pairing it beautifully with עגלים (calves/circles = 153) as the two bracketing springs in Ezekiel's vision. This makes the symmetry even clearer and stronger.The Hidden Geometry of 153: Fish, Sons of God, and Two Young AnimalsJohn 21 tells of a night of empty nets turned into an overwhelming catch: exactly 153 large fish, hauled in on the right side, the net miraculously unbroken.Why 153? For centuries this number has intrigued readers. It is no random detail. Layer by layer, Scripture reveals a stunning web of mathematics, gematria, and wordplay—all pointing to resurrection, cleansing, and the great end-time harvest of souls.1. 153 = The 17th Triangular Number153 is the sum of every integer from 1 to 17:1 + 2 + … + 17 = 153This makes it a perfect triangular number—one that forms an equilateral triang...
Comments
Post a Comment